When Is a Memoir Ready?
By Louisa Deasey
This is one of the most common questions memoir writers ask:
How do I know when my story is ready to share with agents, publishers, or readers?
And it’s exactly why I’m so vocal about the limitations of critiques, beta readers, and early feedback — especially for memoir.
In this post, I want to show you the exact process I used to bring my own memoir to submission standard without critiques, and the story “code” that unlocked everything for me.
This is the same process I now teach inside The Art of Memoir.
Why Most Memoir Writers Stall (& the Draft Never Gets Finished)
Most memoir writers stall because they:
- Don’t yet understand what their story is really about
- Get feedback too early and lose confidence
- Revise blindly without knowing what to cut or keep
- Confuse emotional truth with narrative structure
Because memoir aka personal narrative isn’t just about telling the truth.
It’s about shaping meaning.
And you can’t shape meaning until you’ve written a whole draft and completely told YOURSELF the story.
The Power of the First (Messy) Draft
My first draft of A Letter From Paris was 120,000 words.
It was messy. Unfiltered. Raw. Too long. I remember entire sections, chapters and characters that eventually got condensed or completely removed.
And that;s OK! That’s exactly what my first draft needed to be.
I always tell writers:
👉 It’s far better to have too much than not enough.
Cutting and condensive and revising from material is infinitely easier than trying to add missing threads later.
This is why The Art of Memoir guides you step by step through writing each section of your story so you always have ‘extra’ material. You also learn a page one to complete draft process to write and maintain your:
- Story Outline
- Chapter and sequence map (‘chronology’)
- Consistency
- Weekly momentum
This way, you get the whole story onto the page first — before making decisions about meaning, structure, or revision.
The Story Code That Changes Everything
Inside The Art of Memoir, we work with what I call the Story Star Codes.
One of the most crucial is Code 5 — understanding the function of archetypes in a true story.
This single code will:
- Clarify the real transformation in your memoir
- Reveal the true purpose of key people and events in your personal story
- Make it immediately obvious what needs to be cut
- Turn revision from overwhelming to clear and precise!
Because once you understand function, revision is much simpler. This is how I managed to remove and condense characters so smoothly, because when you have way too many people and players performing the same function in your story, it becomes rambling, boring, and it impacts the pace and plot.
(This Story Star Code intersects with all of them, but mostly an evolutionary story structure and the premise of your book.)
Why You Can’t See the Story Until It’s Written
Here’s the truth most writers resist:
You usually think you’re writing one story…
until you reach the end and realise what the story actually is.
This is not failure! It’s the way the process is meant to flow!
Until the entire draft exists, you cannot:
- Identify the core narrative thread
- Shape a cohesive arc
- Create a compelling reading experience
This is the difference between memoirs that “need development” and memoirs that are publication-ready.
The Second Sweep: Where the Story Emerges
The magic happens in revision — but only if you know what you’re looking for.
When you revise with story structure in mind, something extraordinary happens.
The shape appears.
Almost like a river emerging from rock.
When I revised A Letter From Paris, I cut over 30,000 words — and finally understood the deeper meaning of certain relationships and events.
That clarity changed everything.
Why Agents and Publishers Reject So Many Memoirs
Publishing professionals see the same issues repeatedly:
- Stream-of-consciousness rambling drafts that read like a diary
- Lists of experiences with no narrative cohesion (again, read more like a diary)
- Emotional dumping without structure or purpose to elements of the plot
- Manuscripts that haven’t considered the reader’s experience
Your story is meant to be shaped and developed, not sent out at this point.
Because your reader deserves much more than that, and this is how you turn pages of your life into a cohesive and publication-ready work of literary art.
Do You Need an Editor or Critique?
Not necessarily.
For A Letter From Paris, no one read the manuscript until I sent it to my editor — and that was the third or fourth draft.
You don’t need critiques to shape a book.
You need a complete process.
When you understand:
- Story structure
- Character function
- Narrative flow
- And your OWN long-term values, intentions and motivations…
Revision becomes clear, efficient, and empowering.
The Art of Memoir: A Complete Start-to-Finish Process
The Art of Memoir isn’t:
- A single workshop
- A loose collection of prompts
- A hobby-style writing course
It’s a clear path with a clear outcome:
✔ A finished, publication-standard draft in 3–12 months
✔ A consistent writing routine
✔ A deep shift in how you understand your life and your story
We work through:
Deadline → Routine → Mapping → Drafting → Exploration → Revision → Completion
Nothing is missing.
Why Writers Love This Process
Dozens of writers have completed and published books using this method.
A recurring theme in recent testimonials?
✨ Lightness
✨ Excitement
✨ Joy
Not misery.
Because memoir doesn’t have to be painful to be powerful.
Watch the Free Masterclass: The Art of Memoir
If you’re ready to:
- Finish your memoir
- Stop seeking permission or approval
- Write without critiques or constant feedback
- Shape a story that’s meaningful and publishable
I invite you to watch the free Art of Memoir masterclass.
This is where I walk you through the full process — and show you exactly how these story codes work together.
Leave A Comment